Phase II of the Titan Submarine: Exploring the Kraken Mare effort will focus on advancing the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of the concept by (1) retiring risks found in the Phase I design, (2) gathering new Kraken Sea observations by Cassini, and (3) further defining science goals and instruments to fulfill them; each of these tasks will feed into two COMPASS design sessions. All of these products should ready the Titan Submarine (Titan Sub) concept to a confidence level that allow further NASA investment. The major risks found in the Phase I conceptual design center around vehicle operations in a liquid hydrocarbon sea. Basic physics questions of operating in this cryogen need to be answered. Cryogenic experts at the NASA Glenn Research Center will develop models to explore mixtures and pressures of cryogens and gases and how they would react with a warm submarine. Results from these models will be used to refine the ballast and propulsion system conceptual designs as well as feed into development of a hydrodynamic fluid models at the Pennsylvania State University Applied Research Laboratory for evaluating the conceptual design. Cassini continues to observe both the constituents (remotely) and the depth of the northern Titan Seas. Up-to-date data will be gathered and used as inputs for the modeling mentioned above. These data, along with the above analysis results, will be used to refine the science goals, concept of operations, and instrument suite for the Titan Sub. These activities will be led by the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory. The Phase II efforts will be strengthened by workshops at selected science and cryogenic conferences that will include scientists, cryogenic engineers (including the liquid natural gas industry) respectively, as well as NASA project planners to review the Titan Sub concept and add direction and experience to the challenges it faces. The results of both the above efforts will feed into a COMPASS current engineering design run to update the current Titan Sub conceptual design to mature the concept. Launch and delivery options will be explored (in Phase I funds were not sufficient to design more than the Sub itself) on how to deliver this long cylindrical submarine. Risks of an exposed phased-array antenna to communicate directly back to Earth will also be explored. A second COMPASS run will develop a Titan Sub that would be delivered as part of an orbiter system. The presence of an orbiter would greatly simplify several aspects of the submarine design, especially delivery and communications.
","benefits":"The Titan Sub Phase II study will have several wider benefits: The results of Phase I have already engaged the public with a multitude of news stories, both on the Web and local news programs, with half a million hits on its concept video.17 Most notable is the BBC article18 \\xd2Is Titan Submarine the Most Daring Mission Yet?\\xd3 In addition, the cryogenic Sub's technologies will certainly have impact on the LNG community in the form of pumps, seals, and alternative operating environments. Regardless of the eventual launch date of a Titan submarine, there are several immediate scientific and engineering benefits to the Phase II research, including (1) better understanding of the seas of Titan with the cryogenic modeling tasks, (2) solutions on delivery and operation of extraterrestrial submersibles for other moons, and (3) cryogenic concepts for both NASA's cryogenic fluid management research (cryogenic motors, valves seals, pumps, and instrumentation) and the LNG community.
","releaseStatus":"Released","status":"Completed","viewCount":663,"destinationType":["Outside_the_Solar_System"],"trlBegin":1,"trlCurrent":1,"trlEnd":1,"lastUpdated":"12/18/25","favorited":false,"detailedFunding":false,"projectContacts":[{"contactId":449093,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Steven","lastName":"Oleson","fullName":"Steven R Oleson","fullNameInverted":"Oleson, Steven R","middleInitial":"R","email":"steven.r.oleson@nasa.gov","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","projectContactRole":"Principal_Investigator","projectContactId":546492,"projectId":91426,"programContactRolePretty":"","projectContactRolePretty":"Principal Investigator"},{"contactId":206077,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Jason","lastName":"Hartwig","fullName":"Jason W Hartwig","fullNameInverted":"Hartwig, Jason W","middleInitial":"W","email":"jason.w.hartwig@nasa.gov","receiveEmail":"Unsubscribed","projectContactRole":"Co_Investigator","projectContactId":546493,"projectId":91426,"programContactRolePretty":"","projectContactRolePretty":"Co-Investigator"},{"contactId":257628,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Justin","lastName":"Walsh","fullName":"Justin M Walsh","fullNameInverted":"Walsh, Justin M","middleInitial":"M","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","projectContactRole":"Co_Investigator","projectContactId":546495,"projectId":91426,"programContactRolePretty":"","projectContactRolePretty":"Co-Investigator"},{"contactId":337672,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Michael","lastName":"Paul","fullName":"Michael S Paul","fullNameInverted":"Paul, Michael S","middleInitial":"S","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","projectContactRole":"Co_Investigator","projectContactId":546497,"projectId":91426,"programContactRolePretty":"","projectContactRolePretty":"Co-Investigator"},{"contactId":381769,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Ralph","lastName":"Lorenz","fullName":"Ralph D Lorenz","fullNameInverted":"Lorenz, Ralph D","middleInitial":"D","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","projectContactRole":"Co_Investigator","projectContactId":546494,"projectId":91426,"programContactRolePretty":"","projectContactRolePretty":"Co-Investigator"},{"contactId":397710,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Robert","lastName":"Braun","fullName":"Robert Braun","fullNameInverted":"Braun, Robert","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","projectContactRole":"Co_Investigator","projectContactId":546496,"projectId":91426,"programContactRolePretty":"","projectContactRolePretty":"Co-Investigator"}],"programContacts":[{"contactId":377059,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Phillip","lastName":"Williams","fullName":"Phillip A Williams","fullNameInverted":"Williams, Phillip A","middleInitial":"A","email":"phillip.a.williams@nasa.gov","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","programContactRole":"Program_Director","programContactId":700,"programId":68,"programContactRolePretty":"Program Director","projectContactRolePretty":""},{"contactId":481784,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Vianni","lastName":"Ricano Cadenas","fullName":"Vianni Ricano Cadenas","fullNameInverted":"Ricano Cadenas, Vianni","email":"vianni.ricanocadenas@nasa.gov","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","programContactRole":"Program_Manager","programContactId":686,"programId":68,"programContactRolePretty":"Program Manager","projectContactRolePretty":""}],"leadOrganization":{"organizationId":4860,"organizationName":"Glenn Research Center","acronym":"GRC","organizationType":"NASA_Center","city":"Cleveland","stateTerritoryId":23,"stateTerritory":{"abbreviation":"OH","country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"name":"Ohio","stateTerritoryId":23,"isTerritory":false},"country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"zipCode":"44135","projectId":91426,"projectOrganizationId":574325,"organizationRole":"Lead_Organization","canUserEdit":false,"locationEdit":false,"organizationRolePretty":"Lead Organization","organizationTypePretty":"NASA Center"},"otherOrganizations":[{"organizationId":4860,"organizationName":"Glenn Research Center","acronym":"GRC","organizationType":"NASA_Center","city":"Cleveland","stateTerritoryId":23,"stateTerritory":{"abbreviation":"OH","country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"name":"Ohio","stateTerritoryId":23,"isTerritory":false},"country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"zipCode":"44135","projectId":91426,"projectOrganizationId":574325,"organizationRole":"Lead_Organization","canUserEdit":false,"locationEdit":false,"organizationRolePretty":"Lead Organization","organizationTypePretty":"NASA Center"},{"organizationId":4983,"organizationName":"Georgia Tech Research Corporation","acronym":"GTRC","organizationType":"Academia","city":"Atlanta","stateTerritoryId":2,"stateTerritory":{"abbreviation":"GA","country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"name":"Georgia","stateTerritoryId":2,"isTerritory":false},"country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"zipCode":"30332","projectId":91426,"projectOrganizationId":574323,"organizationRole":"Supporting_Organization","canUserEdit":false,"locationEdit":false,"organizationRolePretty":"Supporting Organization","organizationTypePretty":"Academia"},{"organizationId":3227,"organizationName":"Johns Hopkins University","organizationType":"Academia","city":"Baltimore","stateTerritoryId":3,"stateTerritory":{"abbreviation":"MD","country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"name":"Maryland","stateTerritoryId":3,"isTerritory":false},"country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"zipCode":"21218","murepUnitId":162928,"academicDegreeType":"Private_4_year","projectId":91426,"projectOrganizationId":574324,"organizationRole":"Supporting_Organization","canUserEdit":false,"locationEdit":false,"organizationRolePretty":"Supporting Organization","organizationTypePretty":"Academia"}],"primaryTx":{"taxonomyNodeId":11420,"taxonomyRootId":8817,"parentNodeId":11418,"code":"TX14.1.2","title":"Launch Vehicle Propellant","description":"Launch vehicle propellant technologies include all aspects of propellant handling for both the vehicle and its payload while on the pad and during the ascent and on-orbit deployment phases. This subcategory includes technologies relevant to the commercial launch industry, enabling growth to support NASA Earth-to-orbit needs for cargo, science, and crews.","exampleTechnologies":"Tank/line insulation suitable for atmospheric conditions/ survive ascent environment; composite structures and components and lines for cryogenic application; propellant stratification and management; ascent/staging slosh/ullage collapse/geysering management; vehicle feedline chill and operation; instrumentation/mass gauging to track propellant inventory; autogenous and helium pressurization systems for cryogenic propellants; settled cryogenic fluid operations; quick disconnects (vehicle and payloads)","level":3,"hasChildren":false,"selected":false,"isPrimary":true,"hasInteriorContent":true},"primaryTxTree":[[{"taxonomyNodeId":11417,"taxonomyRootId":8817,"code":"TX14","title":"Thermal Management Systems","level":1,"hasChildren":true,"selected":false,"hasInteriorContent":true},{"taxonomyNodeId":11418,"taxonomyRootId":8817,"parentNodeId":11417,"code":"TX14.1","title":"Cryogenic Systems","description":"Cryogenics is the art of, science of, and engineering involved in achieving below 150°C and involves research, technology development, design, analysis, characterization, and testing of components through ground and flight evaluations that support the qualification and use of cryogenic fluids and temperatures for flight. Cryogenics employs unique skills, facilities, and expertise because the thermodynamics, fluid dynamics, material behaviors, and component and system responses vary significantly at low temperatures. Applications include all aspects of propulsion, science, ground operations, other unique applications, supporting analysis, safety, and testing.","level":2,"hasChildren":true,"selected":false,"hasInteriorContent":true},{"taxonomyNodeId":11420,"taxonomyRootId":8817,"parentNodeId":11418,"code":"TX14.1.2","title":"Launch Vehicle Propellant","description":"Launch vehicle propellant technologies include all aspects of propellant handling for both the vehicle and its payload while on the pad and during the ascent and on-orbit deployment phases. This subcategory includes technologies relevant to the commercial launch industry, enabling growth to support NASA Earth-to-orbit needs for cargo, science, and crews.","exampleTechnologies":"Tank/line insulation suitable for atmospheric conditions/ survive ascent environment; composite structures and components and lines for cryogenic application; propellant stratification and management; ascent/staging slosh/ullage collapse/geysering management; vehicle feedline chill and operation; instrumentation/mass gauging to track propellant inventory; autogenous and helium pressurization systems for cryogenic propellants; settled cryogenic fluid operations; quick disconnects (vehicle and payloads)","level":3,"hasChildren":false,"selected":true,"hasInteriorContent":true}]],"technologyOutcomes":[{"technologyOutcomeId":96491,"projectId":91426,"project":{"projectId":91426,"title":"Titan Submarine: Exploring the Depths of Kraken Mare","startDate":"2015-07-01","startYear":2015,"startMonth":7,"endDate":"2017-06-01","endYear":2017,"endMonth":6,"programId":68,"program":{"ableToSelect":false,"acronym":"NIAC","isActive":true,"description":"The NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts (NIAC) Program nurtures visionary ideas that could transform future NASA missions with the creation of breakthroughs - radically better or entirely new aerospace concepts - while engaging America's innovators and entrepreneurs as partners in the journey. NIAC projects study innovative, technically credible, advanced concepts that could one day \"Change the Possible\" in aerospace. The program is run from NASA Headquarters, Space Technology Mission Directorate.","parentProgram":{"ableToSelect":false,"isActive":true,"description":"Catalyst is a portfolio of early stage programs that specialize in different innovation constituencies and mechanisms to push the state of the art in aerospace technology development","programId":92327,"responsibleMd":{"canUserEdit":false,"locationEdit":false,"organizationRolePretty":"","organizationTypePretty":""},"title":"Catalyst","manageGaps":false,"acronymOrTitle":"Catalyst"},"parentProgramId":92327,"programId":68,"responsibleMd":{"organizationId":4875,"organizationName":"Space Technology Mission Directorate","acronym":"STMD","organizationType":"NASA_Mission_Directorate","canUserEdit":false,"locationEdit":false,"organizationRolePretty":"","organizationTypePretty":"NASA Mission Directorate"},"responsibleMdOffice":4875,"stockImageFileId":36657,"title":"NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts","manageGaps":false,"acronymOrTitle":"NIAC"},"description":"Phase II of the Titan Submarine: Exploring the Kraken Mare effort will focus on advancing the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of the concept by (1) retiring risks found in the Phase I design, (2) gathering new Kraken Sea observations by Cassini, and (3) further defining science goals and instruments to fulfill them; each of these tasks will feed into two COMPASS design sessions. All of these products should ready the Titan Submarine (Titan Sub) concept to a confidence level that allow further NASA investment. The major risks found in the Phase I conceptual design center around vehicle operations in a liquid hydrocarbon sea. Basic physics questions of operating in this cryogen need to be answered. Cryogenic experts at the NASA Glenn Research Center will develop models to explore mixtures and pressures of cryogens and gases and how they would react with a warm submarine. Results from these models will be used to refine the ballast and propulsion system conceptual designs as well as feed into development of a hydrodynamic fluid models at the Pennsylvania State University Applied Research Laboratory for evaluating the conceptual design. Cassini continues to observe both the constituents (remotely) and the depth of the northern Titan Seas. Up-to-date data will be gathered and used as inputs for the modeling mentioned above. These data, along with the above analysis results, will be used to refine the science goals, concept of operations, and instrument suite for the Titan Sub. These activities will be led by the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory. The Phase II efforts will be strengthened by workshops at selected science and cryogenic conferences that will include scientists, cryogenic engineers (including the liquid natural gas industry) respectively, as well as NASA project planners to review the Titan Sub concept and add direction and experience to the challenges it faces. The results of both the above efforts will feed into a COMPASS current engineering design run to update the current Titan Sub conceptual design to mature the concept. Launch and delivery options will be explored (in Phase I funds were not sufficient to design more than the Sub itself) on how to deliver this long cylindrical submarine. Risks of an exposed phased-array antenna to communicate directly back to Earth will also be explored. A second COMPASS run will develop a Titan Sub that would be delivered as part of an orbiter system. The presence of an orbiter would greatly simplify several aspects of the submarine design, especially delivery and communications.
","benefits":"The Titan Sub Phase II study will have several wider benefits: The results of Phase I have already engaged the public with a multitude of news stories, both on the Web and local news programs, with half a million hits on its concept video.17 Most notable is the BBC article18 \\xd2Is Titan Submarine the Most Daring Mission Yet?\\xd3 In addition, the cryogenic Sub's technologies will certainly have impact on the LNG community in the form of pumps, seals, and alternative operating environments. Regardless of the eventual launch date of a Titan submarine, there are several immediate scientific and engineering benefits to the Phase II research, including (1) better understanding of the seas of Titan with the cryogenic modeling tasks, (2) solutions on delivery and operation of extraterrestrial submersibles for other moons, and (3) cryogenic concepts for both NASA's cryogenic fluid management research (cryogenic motors, valves seals, pumps, and instrumentation) and the LNG community.
","releaseStatus":"Released","status":"Completed","destinationType":["Outside_the_Solar_System"],"trlBegin":1,"trlCurrent":1,"trlEnd":1,"favorited":false,"detailedFunding":false,"programContacts":[{"contactId":481784,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Vianni","lastName":"Ricano Cadenas","fullName":"Vianni Ricano Cadenas","fullNameInverted":"Ricano Cadenas, Vianni","email":"vianni.ricanocadenas@nasa.gov","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","programContactRole":"Program_Manager","programContactId":686,"programId":68,"programContactRolePretty":"Program Manager","projectContactRolePretty":""},{"contactId":377059,"canUserEdit":false,"firstName":"Phillip","lastName":"Williams","fullName":"Phillip A Williams","fullNameInverted":"Williams, Phillip A","middleInitial":"A","email":"phillip.a.williams@nasa.gov","receiveEmail":"Subscribed_User","programContactRole":"Program_Director","programContactId":700,"programId":68,"programContactRolePretty":"Program Director","projectContactRolePretty":""}],"endDateString":"Jun 2017","startDateString":"Jul 2015"},"technologyOutcomeDate":"2017-06-01","infusion":"Other","technologyOutcomePath":"Closed_Out","closeoutLinkUrl":"https://www.nasa.gov/feature/titan-submarine-exploring-the-depths-of-kraken-mare","infoText":"Closed out","infoTextExtra":"Project closed out","isIndirect":false,"isBiDirectional":false,"technologyOutcomeDateFullString":"June 2017","technologyOutcomeDateString":"Jun 2017","technologyOutcomePartnerPretty":"","technologyOutcomePathPretty":"Closed Out","infusionPretty":"Other","technologyOutcomeRationalePretty":""}],"primaryImage":{"file":{"fileExtension":"jpg","fileId":365030,"presignedUpload":false,"fileSizeString":"0 Byte"},"libraryItemId":363675,"description":"Artist depiction of Titan Submarine","projectId":91426,"publishedDateString":"","entryDateString":"","libraryItemTypePretty":"","modifiedDateString":""},"libraryItems":[{"files":[],"libraryItemId":363673,"title":"NASA.gov Feature Article","libraryItemType":"Link","url":"https://www.nasa.gov/feature/titan-submarine-exploring-the-depths-of-kraken-mare","projectId":91426,"isPrimary":false,"internalOnly":false,"publishedDateString":"","entryDateString":"01/22/25 01:10 AM","libraryItemTypePretty":"Link","modifiedDateString":"08/22/22 08:59 PM"},{"file":{"fileExtension":"jpg","fileId":365030,"fileName":"oleson_external_components_titan_sub","fileSize":333455,"objectId":363675,"objectType":"libraryItemFiles","presignedUpload":false,"fileSizeString":"325.6 KB"},"files":[{"fileExtension":"jpg","fileId":365030,"fileName":"oleson_external_components_titan_sub","fileSize":333455,"objectId":363675,"objectType":"libraryItemFiles","presignedUpload":false,"fileSizeString":"325.6 KB"}],"libraryItemId":363675,"title":"Project Image","description":"Artist depiction of Titan Submarine","libraryItemType":"Image","projectId":91426,"isPrimary":true,"internalOnly":false,"publishedDateString":"","entryDateString":"01/22/25 01:10 AM","libraryItemTypePretty":"Image","modifiedDateString":"08/22/22 08:59 PM"},{"files":[],"libraryItemId":363676,"title":"Project Website","libraryItemType":"Link","url":"https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/home/index.html","projectId":91426,"internalOnly":false,"publishedDateString":"","entryDateString":"01/22/25 01:10 AM","libraryItemTypePretty":"Link","modifiedDateString":"10/25/24 02:23 PM"},{"files":[],"libraryItemId":363674,"title":"Seven Hundred Leagues Beneath Titan’s Methane Seas","description":"","libraryItemType":"Link","url":"https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/21/science/saturn-titan-moon-exploration.html","projectId":91426,"isPrimary":false,"publishedBy":"","internalOnly":false,"publishedDateString":"","entryDateString":"01/22/25 01:10 AM","libraryItemTypePretty":"Link","modifiedDateString":"08/22/22 08:59 PM"}],"states":[{"abbreviation":"GA","country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"name":"Georgia","stateTerritoryId":2,"isTerritory":false},{"abbreviation":"OH","country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"name":"Ohio","stateTerritoryId":23,"isTerritory":false},{"abbreviation":"PA","country":{"abbreviation":"US","countryId":236,"name":"United States"},"countryId":236,"name":"Pennsylvania","stateTerritoryId":47,"isTerritory":false}],"endDateString":"Jun 2017","startDateString":"Jul 2015"}}